Amidst all the changes you’ve experienced in the last few weeks, like a ton of leaders and pastors, you are likely trying to master the skill of speaking or preaching straight into a camera.
With no audience.
And by now, you’ve realized just how challenging that can be.
As difficult as speaking in front of a live audience is, being in the room with a crowd gives you huge advantages as a communicator.
When you have an audience in the room with you, it’s easy to tell if people are paying attention and whether they’re leaning in. You can sense whether they’re tracking by whether they laugh at your jokes (please, laugh at my jokes…), sitting up during important points, or become so rapt that in moments you can hear a pin drop.
All of that plays into an invisible feedback loop in the speaker or preacher’s mind that gives you cues as to whether to speed up, slow down, move on, dig deeper, relax or make other adjustments as you go.
When there’s no audience, all of that is gone.
I didn’t realize how heavily I relied on my ability to ‘read’ an audience and see how my message is tracking until I spoke straight into the camera in an empty room for the first time.
At first, it felt awful—almost as if I had never spoken before. I had no idea how to adapt.
These days, I shoot hours and hours of video each year with zero audience (just a camera) for everything from pre-recorded sermons, to creating my online courses, to leading webinars and livestreams. For a while I even live hosted a live national TV show (with no studio audience). I’ve learned some things along the way.
This post is part of a series on church leadership and the current global crisis:
Here are a few tips that can help you get used to speaking directly into a camera (with no audience).
1. BE REAL. REAL IS RESONATING, DEEPLY
It’s so tempting to think you’re only as good as your gear. And if you don’t have great gear, a crew, and amazing production, your message won’t resonate.
That’s not the case at all.
The truth is you’re every bit as good as your content and delivery. Gear can help, but in this moment, who you are is resonating far more deeply than the gear you use.
Some church leaders are still doing big production on a stage without the audience, and you could argue that’s what people are longing for (can we please go back to normal?). No criticism here. We’re all trying to figure this out in real-time.
But for some that’s impossible or unwise (health considerations, number of crew needed, or frankly, you never had big production in the first place).
Only having your iPhone or something less than a pro-set up isn’t fatal at all. In fact, it gives you more opportunity than anything.
You can take the pressure off yourself and just be real. Our world needs real more than it needs anything right now.
You know who’s crushing the new low production reality? Jimmy Fallon is.
Jimmy Fallon didn’t try to pretend he wasn’t doing the Tonight Show from home. Instead, he embraced it in all of its ordinariness. Which is exactly what makes it work.
If you haven’t seen it yet, he’s filming the entire Tonight Show from various places in his home with his wife as camera operator and video linking to guests in their homes. Here’s a link to one episode with John Legend, and another with Alec Baldwin and 5 Seconds of Summer.Jimmy Fallon didn’t try to pretend he wasn’t doing the Tonight Show from home. Instead, he embraced it in all of its ordinariness.
As you flip through the episodes, notice that Jimmy:
- Doesn’t compete with his family…he includes them. His daughters make all the art for the show.
- Reads his monologue from a printed sheet, the same way you’d read something in a meeting or casual conversation. That actually makes it funnier, because even someone with the gifting of Fallon realizes that without the studio audience there, it would be really difficult to get the delivery right.
- Wears the clothes you’d normally wear at home (no suits).
- The audio quality is really crazy low…including the musical guests (literally no mic other than the iPhone in a bricked room).
- Does a low res Skype/Zoom iPhone interview with Alec Baldwin on his iPhone with his wife and daughter hanging out in the background.
- Raises money for a new charity every night to try to help with the crisis.
The best part? It’s so real.
Rather than compete with the situation we’re all in, Fallon embraces it. And while he has a few more zeros in front of the decimals in his bank balance than you and I do, he brings himself into the reality we’re all in. He went where his audience lives: to his home, adapting like everyone else.
Theologians might call that kind of approach incarnational. Incarnational is one approach our world is longing for right now.
Being with your people in a time like this means being real with your people in a time like this.
Deciding to be real is strangely, even more calming and anchoring than constant hype or constant hope.
2. PICTURE YOUR AUDIENCE
Real is one thing, but how do you connect when you can’t see your audience?
Simple: imagine them.
Pick a person you know and talk to them. Maybe it’s an unchurched friend you’re trying to reach, a new attender you just met or a long time member you trust deeply. Just pick a person and speak to them.
Naturally, you can vary that from talk to talk or live-stream to live stream, but it really breaks down the digital wall.
When I record my leadership podcast I imagine a leader out for his morning run or in her car listening to the episode. I think about what he or she is struggling with and I try to speak directly to them.
When I film one of my online courses, I imagine a senior pastor listening and trying to apply it to his or her church, or a staff team trying to make it work in their context.
When I preach to a camera, I imagine room full of people, or in this case, a living room with a family.
All of that helps.
Imagining your audience will make your tone of voice more expressive and empathetic as well as more natural. And it will even help you think about whether your content is really going to help the people watching or listening.
If you imagine your audience when you’re speaking into a camera, you’re far more like to connect with them.
3. SHORTEN IT
My general rule on live communication with a crowd is that there’s no magic length for the perfect sermon or keynote.
While TED talks have changed the game, there’s nothing magic about 18 minutes: 5 minutes of boring is 5 minutes too long and 60 minutes of fascinating isn’t nearly enough. I still stand by that for live communication.
Video, though, is different to me. People listen to podcasts and watch videos at 1.5 or 2x speed. And I don’t know why, but two minutes still seems like an eternity on YouTube. Know what I mean?
For that reason, my rule of thumb on video (with no live audience) is that shorter is better.
I’m up this Sunday, and instead of speaking 38-40 minutes, I plan on doing no more than 25 minutes. It just feels much longer when there’s no one in the room.
Plus, if you look at the reality of what’s happening in the average home, kids are crawling all over parents, half your audience might be cleaning up breakfast while ‘worshipping’ and it’s pretty easy to open multiple tabs on your laptop if you get bored.
This might change over time, but I would leave your congregation wanting more than having them wish you had been done ten minutes ago.
Remember, online viewing is much less polite than an in-person congregation. To walk out during a message takes guts. To swipe out of the message takes nothing…and nobody would ever know.
4. DON’T TRY TO RECREATE WHAT’S GONE
As I shared in an earlier post about how to lead in a digital default church, that you’re probably spending a lot of time doing right now is figuring out how to do what you used to do.
Um, that’s gone. It’s history.
Again, back to Fallon, rather than trying to build the Tonight Show set in his back yard, he just embraced the fact that all of that was gone for now.
I’m not criticizing preachers who have a camera set up in an empty auditorium (I will likely preach that way this weekend…it’s what our church is still able to do), but don’t just re-create. Experiment.
I plan on adding a live-stream Q and A at the end of the message.
And video is endlessly creative.
A friend who leads a mega-church, and has a huge love of movies, screenplays and great art, texted me and asked if finally all the energy he’d love to put into cinema (he wanted to write screenplays) could be put into the message. I didn’t blink. Of course it could.
Don’t spend your energy trying to recreate what was lost. Try to find something new.
When the audience isn’t in the room, new ways open up to connect with the audience.
Let this crisis be a cradle for innovation.
5. TAKE PEOPLE BACKSTAGE
And by backstage, I mean into your life.
My pastor, Jeff Brodie, smartly opened his message by showing pictures of his family and how everything changed in the last few weeks at his house. Fun, personal and real.
I speak around the world (or at least used to) on leadership, write books, host leadership podcasts and breathe leadership every day. But if you check my Instagram feed (especially stories), it’s a hybrid mix of my leadership ideas, and my life—going out for a run or bike ride, smoking brisket on my Big Green Egg, getting my first COVID haircut, and in the summer obsessing over the lines in my (hopefully very green) lawn.
When I land in a city to speak (on leadership), you know what the top things people talk to me about? It’s often not leadership. Instead, they talk to me about my obsessions with my lawn and barbecuing on the Big Green Egg.
People may love what you say, but they identify with you.
In an age where everything is spun, sold and marketed, people are looking for you. Let them see, well, you.
Quick tip for preachers. People think you say what you say because you get paid to say it. I know that’s crass and it’s not true, but that’s the thought-bubble over people’s heads when they interact with a preacher.
Letting people see that you’re real helps people see that God is real.
I guess we’re back at point 1, but that really is something that will get you so far in the midst of this crisis. And well beyond it.
BONUS TIP: WATCH YOURSELF
As painful as it is, watch yourself on video.
I know…I still cringe, noticing every little mistake I make.
If you’re really brave—which you should be—get others to evaluate you and give you tips.
Pain can be a great teacher.
If you can’t stand to watch yourself on video, why would anyone else watch you?
BECOME A BETTER COMMUNICATOR…STARTING TODAY
As much as the digital reality has changed everything, some of the core principles of sermon preparation and excellent communication never change. Great communication is simple great communication.
If you’re ready to start preaching better sermons and reach the unchurched without selling out, then it’s time to start using the right tips, lessons, and strategies to communicating better.
The Art of Better Preaching Course is a 12 session video training with a comprehensive, interactive workbook that will help you create, write, and deliver better sermons. The course contains the lessons Mark Clark (lead pastor of Village Church, a growing mega-church in post-Christian Vancouver) and I have learned, taught, and used over decades of being professional communicators.
This is the complete course you need to start preaching better sermons, including:
- 7 preaching myths it’s time to bust forever
- The 5 keys to preaching sermons to unchurched people (that will keep them coming back)
- How to discover the power in the text (and use it to drive your sermon)
- The specific characteristics of sermons that reach people in today’s world
- Why you need to ditch your sermon notes (and how to do it far more easily than you think.)
- How to keep your heart and mind fresh over the long run
And far more! Plus you get an interactive workbook and some bonus resources that will help you write amazing messages week after week.
In the Art of Better Preaching, Mark and I share everything we’ve learned about communicating in a way that will help your church grow without compromising biblical integrity. We cover detailed training on everything from interacting with the biblical text to delivering a talk without using notes, to writing killer bottom lines that people will remember for years.
Don’t miss out! Check it out today and gain instant access.
WHAT HELPS YOU?
What helps you when speaking directly to the camera?
Scroll down and leave a comment!